Hailey was fabulous is a glossy black leather jacket with oversize sleeves, a hood, and an elastic detail that cinched it at the waist, creating the illusion of a miniskirt. She wore the bulky outerwear as a minidress, paring it only with sheer black tights and pointy black pumps—one of her favorite combinations.

Hailey and Justin Bieber have a shared fashion formula: In that, they do the polar opposite of what the other one does. Photographed heading out for dinner in New York, Hailey and Justin Bieber kept up their oscillating stylistic spectrum.